MAHA Commission Presents a Roadmap With Few Tangible Policies | Civil Eats
USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins, Health & Human Services Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Domestic Policy Council Director Vince Haley, and EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin at the press conference releasing the MAHA Commission report today. (Photo credit: Lisa Held)

MAHA Commission Presents a Roadmap With Few Tangible Policies

Nutrition and public health advocates say the report contains a range of ideas with no specific policy or funding teeth.

September 9, 2025 – During a press event at the Department of Health and Human Services  headquarters on Tuesday, the Trump administration released its highly anticipated Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) roadmap for confronting chronic diseases, with suggested reforms to the food, nutrition, and agriculture sectors.

Unlock the Full Story with a Civil Eats Membership

Expand your understanding of food systems as a Civil Eats member. Enjoy unlimited access to our groundbreaking reporting, engage with experts, and connect with a community of changemakers.

Join today

The event lacked the MAHA fanfare around the first report’s release last May, and many nutrition experts that have supported the movement’s calls to address the root cause of diseases through food say the latest report lacks tangible policies and largely returns to the status quo of industry influence.

Led by Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the MAHA Commission document builds on the panel’s first assessment of possible drivers of chronic disease rates among children.

The first report named ultra-processed foods, pesticides, and food chemicals as potential contributors to negative health outcomes. This latest document does not go as far as some nutrition experts and public health groups hoped.

“The first report was revolutionary in a good way. RFK Jr., had made this issue of food-caused chronic disease a political priority,” said Jerry Mande, CEO of Nourish Science and former USDA Food, Nutrition and Consumer Services official. “This report seems to have been written by an entirely different group of people.”

Some of the policy recommendations on food and nutrition include planned revisions to proposed guidance for a Front-of-Pack labeling requirement, completion of the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, and continued encouragement of the voluntary removal of artificial food dyes.

Marion Nestle, a leading nutrition expert and a member of the Civil Eats Advisory Board, said the report includes a lot of ideas but is short on specifics and tangible regulatory steps.

“This is such an opportunity. I sure wish they had taken it,” Nestle said in an email. “MAHA has so much bipartisan support. This was the time to regulate food marketing to kids—not ‘explore’” regulations.

This would have been the right moment to “get ultra-processed foods out of schools, and promote farm-to-school programs and school gardens—all shown to improve kids’ dietary intake,” she wrote. “Where’s the policy?”

banner showing a radar tracking screen and the words

She also noted some of the contradictions in what the report lists versus the administration’s actions.

Earlier this spring, for example, the Trump administration canceled multiple programs focused on increasing local foods in schools and food banks.

During an event discussing the report on Tuesday, Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins announced a revised farm-to-school program. She said this revision would include a streamlined application process and expand access for small family farms to markets and federal nutrition programs. It was not clear, however, which specific U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) program she was referring to. The farm-to-school policy was also mentioned in the MAHA strategy.

When asked if this announcement meant the local food programs would resume, Calley Means, a special government employee and MAHA ally to Kennedy, told reporters he couldn’t get into the specifics. But he said Rollins’ announcement signals the administration’s goal of creating markets for local farmers to put local, fresh food on children’s plates.

Another major feature of the new MAHA report was a stated intention of the administration to improve nutrition education, particularly after the upcoming dietary guidelines are released. But as Mande pointed out, the Republican’s One Big Beautiful Bill cut $500 million in SNAP-Ed funding, a program that promoted nutrition education. That was a significant and unprecedented amount of funds for a nutrition initiative, Mande said.

“They’re the federal government, they don’t need to call for these things. They need to do these things,” Mande said. “And to do these things requires funding or regulation, and they really shy away from that.”

While public health groups agreed with some of the policy priorities listed in the report, they pointed out its lack of details, including strong enforcement mechanisms.

“In the rare cases it gets right, as it does with closing the GRAS loophole, details are sparse,” Peter Lurie, president of the Center for Science in the Public Interest, said in a statement. “And even in the case of food dyes, the administration is pointedly deciding not to use its regulatory authority to spur progress.”

Still, some MAHA supporters remained optimistic over the actions outlined in the report.

We’ll bring the news to you.

Get the weekly Civil Eats newsletter, delivered to your inbox.

In an interview with Fox News, Vani Hari, also known as the Food Babe, said the MAHA Commission’s strategy will “declare a war on ultraprocessed foods.” The document claims the administration will continue work to define these foods, but it does not refer to these products directly again.

“The reduction of ultraprocessed foods in the American diet will change our farming practices, will reduce the reliance on chemical intensive agriculture by default,” Hari said.

Zen Honeycutt, founder of Moms Across America, said she was concerned that specific pesticides like glyphosate and atrazine weren’t mentioned in the report, but she acknowledged that the commission was being “strategically vague” because of intense opposition from industry groups.

“The report addresses over a dozen environmental factors that have never been addressed by any administration previously in a meaningful way, so we are thrilled about this historical document,” Honeycutt said. (Link to this post.)

You’d be a great Civil Eats member…

Civil Eats is a reader-supported, nonprofit newsroom, and we count on our members to keep producing our award-winning work.

Readers like you are the reason why we’re able to keep digging deep into stories you won’t find anywhere else. When you become a member, your support directly funds our journalism—from paying our reporters to keeping the internet on in our remote offices across the United States.

Your membership will also come with great benefits, including our award-winning newsletter, The Deep Dish, which is full of relevant and timely reporting, access to our members’ Slack community, and online salons as a way to engage with reporters, food and agriculture experts, and each other.

Civil Eats Supporting Membership $60/year $6/month
Give One, Get One Membership $100/year
Learn more about our membership program

Rebekah Alvey is a staff reporter for Civil Eats. Read more >

Lisa Held is Civil Eats’ senior staff reporter and contributing editor. Read more >

Like the story?
Join the conversation.

Leave a Comment

More from

Food Policy Tracker

Featured

HARRINGTON, MAINE - AUGUST 08: Brandon Mott loads boxes of wild blueberries onto a truck as they harvest them from the plants in the fields of independent wild Maine blueberry grower Lynch Hill Farms on August 08, 2025 in Harrington, Maine. Independent wild Maine blueberry growers in the state are experiencing challenging times as their crops face several threats posed by climate change, from increased frequency of extreme weather events like droughts, floods, destructive frost, and warmer temperatures. Courtney Hammond, Lynch Hill Farms Manager, thinks his business is possibly in jeopardy as his crops are producing fewer marketable berries than normal. He, along with other independent growers, continues to try to adapt to the weather, but they could be reaching the point of no return, said Mr. Hammond. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

A Key Agriculture Census Doesn’t Reflect Reality, Researcher Warns

In a recent paper, University of Iowa professor Silvia Secchi finds that the current Census of Agriculture is neither complete nor accurate, and could skew federal research and investment.

Popular

At Farm Aid, Top Agriculture Democrats Say Trump’s Policies Are Hurting Farmers

Senator Amy Klobuchar (D-Minnesota) speaks on stage at Farm Aid 40 in Minnesota. (Photo credit: Lisa Held)

Rural Development Experts Warn Against USDA Cuts at Local Offices

The U.S. Department of Agriculture headquarters, with the Civil Eats Food Policy Tracker logo superimposed. (Photo credit: Art Wagner, Getty Images)

House Republicans Block Tariff Challenges

The US Capitol building, where Congress meets. (Photo credit: Andrey Denisyuk, Getty Images)

Democrats Decry Corporate Consolidation ‘at Every Single Level’ of the Food System

the cereal aisle of the grocery store is full of ultraprocessed foods. (Photo credit: Katrina Wittkamp, Getty Images)